Which meal is more heart healthy, the steak or the sandwich? If you believe the American government, and the media, and the vast majority of medical professionals, then it’s no contest. The veggie sandwich is a better choice for heart health because it contains no cholesterol or fat. The steak, on the other hand, has been vilified for decades because we’ve been told that eating foods that contain fat (especially saturated fat) raises the level of cholesterol in your blood and high levels of LDL cholesterol in your blood increases your risk of heart disease.
Signed. Sealed. Delivered. Yes? Not so fast.
What if I told you there has been a vast conspiracy to condemn fat in order to bury the evidence that the real enemy of heart health is sugar? Would you tell me I am crazy and to lose the tin foil hat? Are you willing to risk your life on it?
Lately some of my friends and family have been telling me I sound like Oliver Stone barking about the Kennedy assassination when it comes to sugar. They’d like me to turn down the volume a bit and stop being such a fun suck. Sugar is a vice, but it’s not the root of all dietary evil they say. Shut up and eat a cookie for crying out loud!
Okay, I admit I’ve been ranting a bit too much lately. But if you’d read what I’ve been reading you’d be disturbed as well. And if you’d had a heart attack at a young age like me and have been in a life and death struggle to figure out how to keep it from happening again you might be more open to alternative theories.
The fact is, there is mounting evidence that sugar is the root cause of heart disease. Rather than treat you to a series of quotes from various authors, doctors, and scientific studies I’ll simply list some resources for you to explore on your own at the end of this post. But suffice it to say, I’ve seen enough evidence to convince me that fat has gotten a raw deal and sugar has been artificially and immorally propped up by the sugar industry itself as a simple vice that is fine in moderation. Hell, at first it was literally endorsed as a health food.
I’ve been on a personal journey to protect my heart for nearly a decade now, and at every turn I run into more evidence that sugar (and processed carbohydrates) is the cause of heart disease. Despite the fact that the government, and even my own employer the American Heart Association, still points the finger at fat and cholesterol. It’s frustrating to see how slow this ship is turning. But I believe it is indeed turning and that in the very near future the health powers that be will be forced to issue a gigantic mea culpa and set us all on the path to healthier hearts.
Over the holidays I finally read The Case Against Sugar by Gary Taubes. You don’t have to read it to learn what he uncovered about the dastardly deeds of the sugar industry — you can Google it and read any number of reviews and interviews with Taubes like this one in the New York Times. Here’s a highlight:
Sugar is not only the root cause of today’s diabetes and obesity epidemics (had these been infectious diseases, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention would have long ago declared an emergency), but also, according to Taubes, is probably related to heart disease, hypertension, many common cancers and Alzheimer’s.
Taubes is a journalist and a well educated one at that. He has degrees from Harvard, Stanford, and Columbia. He has won numerous awards for his work, including the Science in Society Journalism Award of the National Association of Science Writers. He is legit. But he’s not alone in this fight for dietary truth. My explorations have led me to some amazing journalists and health professionals who have all reached the same conclusions about sugar. Like Dr. Stephen Sinatra. Dr. Mark Hyman. Dr. Zoe Harcombe. And Nina Teicholz, science journalist and author of The Big Fat Surprise.
I have also been experimenting with my own body. The fewer carbs and added sugars I eat, the better my blood work turns out. I recently had a nuclear stress test and an echocardiogram as part of my cardiovascular follow-up care, and my cardiologist said my heart is pumping at full power and all the images indicate my heart is healthy. My most recent blood work reported total cholesterol at 118, triglycerides at 120 and LDL at 55. These numbers are enviable for anyone regardless of heart history.
I believe my heart attack was caused by a single blocked artery that became blocked from years of a high carb, high added sugar diet that caused my triglycerides to skyrocket. My trigs were so high at one point (north of 700) that it skewed by total cholesterol numbers to the point that they couldn’t be accurately measured. Ironically, I was not eating an unhealthy diet according to the U.S. government. In fact, I was eating the recommended diet of low fat, high carbs. Journalists like Taubes and Teicholz have uncovered how and why the U.S. dietary guidelines went so astray, but in a nutshell, the reason is sugar. Much like how the tobacco industry lied and manipulated the science and policy of cigarettes, the sugar industry did the same. The evidence is clear.
Sugar is toxic. It screws with your endocrine system, forcing your body to produce too much insulin, which in turn causes you to become insulin resistant. Insulin resistance causes increased production of fat in the bloodstream which causes both obesity and plaque in your arteries. That’s my nonscientific explanation, but if you want to understand it in more detail you can read more on your own.
So back to that question at the top of this post. Which is healthier for the heart, the steak or the sandwich? Well, the 6-inch Veggie Delight from Subway has 41 grams of carbs and the steak has none. Carbs are sugar. Sugar equals heart disease.
If you want to live a heart-healthy life, don’t listen to the government. Listen to science.